• When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.

Signed cards & grade
1 1

7 posts in this topic

9 hours ago, CardGrader said:

No, all manufacturer autos (pack-pulled) must have the auto graded.

 

Interesting.  I was an early adopter and I paid for the auto grading but y’all returned them to me without them.  Not bringing it up as a complaint on my part.  I don’t mind eating the $10 and don’t want to deal with a resub to fix.

FB43829A-5919-484A-BEDA-8B2DAF249E2A.jpeg

0EF91630-A861-440C-9650-06A3658538F1.jpeg

D172EAC2-742E-4CE2-A05C-63FC96B42B2B.jpeg

5024F74F-1E6C-4FB0-AEDC-F8AEBEC7401D.jpeg

1B36BF62-E952-4F8E-8AF3-A2D3A2ACBFD9.jpeg

66E2A349-6411-4FD7-9AE0-7ECB0DAA18E1.jpeg

3017C511-03A5-411E-92C8-2C32199EE762.jpeg

6FD7B52C-08B0-4E51-9CFD-F40E742194C1.jpeg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, kled2000 said:

Interesting.  I was an early adopter and I paid for the auto grading but y’all returned them to me without them.  Not bringing it up as a complaint on my part.  I don’t mind eating the $10 and don’t want to deal with a resub to fix.

FB43829A-5919-484A-BEDA-8B2DAF249E2A.jpeg

0EF91630-A861-440C-9650-06A3658538F1.jpeg

D172EAC2-742E-4CE2-A05C-63FC96B42B2B.jpeg

5024F74F-1E6C-4FB0-AEDC-F8AEBEC7401D.jpeg

1B36BF62-E952-4F8E-8AF3-A2D3A2ACBFD9.jpeg

66E2A349-6411-4FD7-9AE0-7ECB0DAA18E1.jpeg

3017C511-03A5-411E-92C8-2C32199EE762.jpeg

6FD7B52C-08B0-4E51-9CFD-F40E742194C1.jpeg

you got lucky/unlucky depending how you look at it... that's crazy

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Glass half full kind of thing...  I graded them more for preservation than secondary value.  Auto grades are certainly something that an average collector shouldn’t really rely on to determine if they like the way the signature looks IMO.  I’m indifferent towards the “grade” of an auto and rely more on the aesthetic of the auto to determine if I favor one vs another...

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, ItismeH said:

you got lucky/unlucky depending how you look at it... that's crazy

 

Glass half full kind of thing...  I graded them more for preservation than secondary value.  Auto grades are certainly something that an average collector shouldn’t really rely on to determine if they like the way the signature looks IMO.  I’m indifferent towards the “grade” of an auto and rely more on the aesthetic of the auto to determine if I favor one vs another...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't understand CardGrader's comment. If it is a requirement for all pack pulled manufacturer autos to be graded then why do you offer the check box for auto grading on your submission form? Cards with other autographs are not eligible for CSG certification. That means you only grade pack pulled autos.

There should be a blanket statement that says "All cards with manufacturer certified autos will be graded regardless whether you (the owner) wants them to or not and we are going to charge you $2 to do so." That way people know what they are getting into when they submit. Very misleading on your website and I can see someone making a big issue of it if they didn't want the auto grade and you force them to pay for it.

It is my option whether I want you to just grade the card or if I want you to grade the card and the auto. In that case, you owe kled2000 either some auto grades or, since you charge them anyway, you owe him $2 per card that did not receive an auto grade.

Edited by tmoore_25
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
1 1