Grading for a miscut card 1 1

[Cicnews4you]

I’m trying to determine if some cards are worthy of grading.  I reviewed your grading criteria and a miscut card is difficult to determine the grade.  If a card such as the one attached want would be the highest grade it could get with sharp corners.  Thanks.  Appreciated

 

charley

[RyanCSG]

On 3/19/2023 at 3:33 PM, Cicnews4you said:

I’m trying to determine if some cards are worthy of grading.  I reviewed your grading criteria and a miscut card is difficult to determine the grade.  If a card such as the one attached want would be the highest grade it could get with sharp corners.  Thanks.  Appreciated

 

charley

Good Morning,

I reached out to the CSG grading team and was told the following in regard to your Roberto Clemente card:

The miscut is pretty standard and it's not bad enough to notate. Since centering is taken into account, it would be in the VG 3 grade range. 

 

[Cicnews4you]

On 3/21/2023 at 8:51 AM, RyanCSG said:

Good Morning,

I reached out to the CSG grading team and was told the following in regard to your Roberto Clemente card:

The miscut is pretty standard and it's not bad enough to notate. Since centering is taken into account, it would be in the VG 3 grade range. 

 

Thanks for your response.  It is appreciated.